Canadian Auto Workers (CAW) down in Oshawa are blockading their soon to be defunct GM truck plant. GM recently announced they are closing the gas guzzler plant in 2009 and gave layoff notices to all the workers. Seems the economy won’t support these behemoths anymore, and the public is telling GM with it’s wallet – the trucks just don’t sell in the numbers they used to. I read sales are down as much as 39% in the last year – this was BEFORE the huge gas price hikes here in Ontario. The truck/SUV crunch is so bad, GM is closing not just the Canadian plant but the ones in the US and Mexico. So what are the workers doing? Saving their pennies in anticipation of layoffs? Looking for employment? Pressuring for aid in creating new jobs? Going to work so they can save their pennies? Not on your Nellie! They are blockading the plant so no work can occur. Bright bulbs down there eh? The CAW wants GM to keep the plant open to 2011 and are using strong arm tactics to make this happen, there was even talk of a strike (oh wouldn’t that make the GM management happy, fewer pay-cheques!) and now the union is promising “We’ve got all kinds of things up our sleeves”. My mind shutters at such nonsense talk. The plant is losing a ton of money, and there is no market for the product, so let’s keep making the trucks so they can sit on a lot, rusting in the Canadian weather. Good plan there folks. Lots of forward thinking.
The time of the big truck has passed. All this stupidity being spewed about forcing the company to keep the plant open won’t help. The jobs are gone, it’s time to move into another sector. Yes I realize your next job won’t pay as well. I had a hard time pinning down how much the workers were making down there – anywhere from $35 for entry level jobs to $70hr for experienced workers. All I know is this is way too much money for unskilled labour. Nurses get paid less than CAW members get paid – to me that is just nuts. I got into an argument with a CAW supporter last week, and he kept saying well they work hard for their money. And the rest of the world doesn’t? Are you telling me a night shift nurse doesn’t work hard? Tell that to them at 7am after a full night. I think the average nurse might just want to rip you a new one. You want to work hard? Go work in a restaurant waiting tables – you don’t even get paid minimum wage and the tips often don’t bridge the gap. Let’s not even discuss the level of abuse you take as a waiter/waitress. THAT’S HARD WORK! This argument makes me see red. CAW members were grossly overpaid, and while that is not the driving reason for the truck sales drops, it sure hasn’t helped.
I feel for the families that are going to be out of work in a year. I also feel for the spin off job loss that will happen. BUT, the writing was on the wall a long time ago. These big, inefficient vehicles, manufactured by the same company that thought the HUMMER, Civilian Crusher Version, was a great idea, are too expensive to run, and chuck way too much pollution into the air. Do you really need a 1/2 ton truck to go pick up milk and cookies at the store? People are concerned about pollution and gas prices. As someone who has suffered through many pollution alerts, I am not shedding a tear for this change in the public attitude. It has been too long in coming. Either we change our habits, or we die. Smaller, more fuel efficient cars that don’t send as much pollution into the air will only benefit us, not hurt us. GM didn’t listen and now it’s paying the piper.
I’ve been reading the editorials and am fed up with the whining and complaining about people buying “crap foreign, Asian cars” instead of Canadian trucks. Wake up you jackasses! GM is not a Canadian company, nor is Ford or any of the rest of them. As for crap? I think the little cars won the battle because the companies LISTENED TO THE BLOODY MARKET! Instead of being inflexible and saying Americans won’t buy small, the Japanese car makers set up car plants here in Canada and have been slowly expanding ever since. Their marketing people looked at the same stats that the Big 3 American car makers looked at and interpreted them correctly. They saw a need for fuel efficient cars and filled that need. What did GM and the rest do? Kept churning out gas guzzlers. Big, dangerous gas, guzzlers. Not hard to guess who is winning the battle?
So CAW, don’t even think of trying to get the Ontario government to strong arm GM into keeping a money losing plant open. This will be a huge waste of tax payers money. Money better spent elsewhere, like on our struggling farmers, poor working class, hungry children in low income families, FLIPPING SCHOOL BOOKS, anything but a damned bunch of trucks that shouldn’t be on the road to begin with. How about being creative instead? Ask for funds to set up alternative employment – oh yes and this also means no more big pay cheques, and welcome back into the real world. Stop screaming for an unrealistic goal and plan now for the future, cause it’s roaring up in your rear view mirror right now.
If you liked that post, then try these...
Stumble it!
4 responses so far ↓
1
Doug
// Jun 9, 2008 at 9:01 pm
GM and the other ‘big three’ didn’t anticipate skyrocketing fuel prices. Neither did the general population which is suffering under a heavy inflation burden. Why you are for the destruction of good-paying jobs in this environment makes no sense. The idea is to bring everyone up, not drag them down. The destruction of good-paying union jobs hurts everyone, including the nurses and the waitresses. And from which fantasy did you get figures of $35 to $70 an hour? I agree that trying to keep a plant that produces inefficient vehicles open is ludicrous, but that isn’t the intention of the CAW leadership. What they are doing is trying to diffuse the anger of the union membership before it becomes a real danger. The truth is that the unions – and in particular the CAW – are junior partners of the corporations.
2
catpaw
// Jun 9, 2008 at 9:33 pm
What fantasy? Try the newspapers pal! That’s where I get the figure. Also, good paying? Absurd pay for unskilled labour.
AND IF YOU HAD READ WHAT I SAID – sales had dropped BEFORE the gas prices rose. As for not anticipating the sky rocketing prices. Again, try reading the papers – gas companies have been saying the prices will skyrocket for years. If this is a shock to GM and the rest, then they need to wake up.
Diffuse the anger? Sorry, no sympathy for a situation Buzz and the boys helped create.
I have nothing against good pay – I get angry at the sense of entitlement that goes along with these jobs.
These big trucks are a liability and the market is proving that.
I wholeheartedly disagree with what you say about trying to head off the anger. If anything the CAW is making it worse by not pursuing possible alternative jobs for it’s membership. Let’s force GM to keep making trucks that don’t sell, is that your solution?
3
Doug
// Jun 9, 2008 at 11:03 pm
Try the collective agreement pay scales for a little more unbiased source of worker’s pay rates. You should know that newspapers lie and distort to further the interests of those who own them and those they represent.
Also I regret that you don’t understand my perspective, and that is that the unions have become junior partners to the corporations and work against the interests of those they are supposed to represent.
The CAW is working to find alternative employment in corporate friendly yet unionised environments like Magna, where they’ve given up fundamental rights in order to keep the dues income a rollin’ in. For those who remain in the auto factories, they can enjoy the corporate-friendly concessions that Buzz has arranged for them. And let’s not forget our friends the UAW that are agreeing to historic wage rollbacks lowering income to near poverty levels in the US of A. And thank both the UAW and CAW for employing nationalist rhetoric to play both sides off against each other in the race to the bottom.
My solution is to throw out the union bureacracy and build an international movement encompassing all workers in the struggle against their common enemy the capitalist profit system, a parasitic system that the unions work for and that benefits only the wealthy at the expense of everyone else including you.
4
catpaw
// Jun 10, 2008 at 10:40 am
I tried to find the collective agreement and the figures I found were the only ones. I’ll look again.
We do agree on the point about union bureacracy – I truly believe it is one of the biggest hinderances to wage equality. Union bosses never seem to suffer during strikes or roll backs.
We also agree on the nonsense about nationalistic rhetoric. I find it sickening to the extreme. And at times borders on racism.
I have a question. Are you sincere about your last comment? Or did you read your Marx and Engels very carefully and are yanking my chain? Because your idea harkens back to the early days of unionization and workers movements – unions that worked hard to protect the workers not feed off them.
Leave a Comment